First Merger Meeting for Seattle Schools, November 17, 2026

 Before I get to this meeting, if anyone listened into the virtual community meeting held last night, please let us know what was said. 

I never did find out when all the merger meetings are being held. Those include:

- Montlake ES and Stevens ES

- Sandpoint ES and Laurelhurst ES

- Rainier View ES and Rising Star ES

- Decatur ES and View Ridge ES

Did those meetings happen already? Let me know if you have intel on them.


But there WAS a meeting last night in West Seattle with the communities of Sanislo ES and Highland Park ES at HPES. Superintendent Ben Shuldiner was front and center. It was covered by the West Seattle Blog and the Seattle Times. Here's is the West Seattle Blog's coverage.

I do want to point out something first, though, that happened that is somewhat shocking. From the West Seattle Blog's Tracy Record (bold mine):

EDITOR’S NOTE: We learned about this meeting – as we had of the one at Sanislo two years ago – from affected schools’ family members forwarding district messages. They asked us to cover the meeting, and we told them we were planning on it. 

After we arrived and sat down on the side of the room, we were told by a district official that the meeting was not open to the media and that we needed to leave. We refused. In his opening remarks, the superintendent subsequently warned those in attendance that your editor was there (without naming me; I raised my hand high so everyone could see) and reiterated that I had been asked to leave. Several people vocally objected (thank you). 

The superintendent went on to say our presence made the meeting “unsafe” for families. We don’t know what that was supposed to mean, as no sensitive or personal information was requested or offered; as a journalist since age 17, I deeply believe that to the contrary, in a situation like this where elected officials are going to make an impactful decision involving public money, public land, and community members, more information being available – responsibly, accurately, and impartially reported – to more people sooner is actually a “safer” and better thing.

The meeting was already well under way when a woman came in, sat down next to me, and started taking notes in longhand. I didn’t know until she emailed me today that she was a Times education reporter and they only let her in because I was there. 

I’m sorry to hear other community members were excluded; as noted above, the superintendent said they have a plan for community-inclusive meetings, but if they consider this the “middle” of the process already, that would have to be considered “late.” 

Comment 1:

I so appreciate your refusal to leave. We were told that they then let in other news media (Seattle Times) and would probably have to open all future merger meetings between the rest of the proposed schools to news media as well. 

Way to strike a blow for openness in public processes!

Comment 2

Thank you for being there and reporting on what was said. As a concerned next door neighbor to one of the schools, I tried to attend and was physically barred from entering since I was not a family member.

Not good at all. Closing/merging schools is a LEGAL process. I realize this was not a public hearing but people don't go to meetings to hide in a corner. I doubt very much that anyone was upset that the media was there. Good for Tracy Record and I want to reiterate something she said so it's clear. 

I am not a journalist. I am a citizen reporter and that is what I have always called myself. That being said, I do call myself media. However, Record IS a journalist and has been for decades. To try to turn her away is shameful and I hope there is no repeat of this anywhere else as this process goes on. 

I have to wonder what the Times' article will say. 


To the meat of the meeting and what I learned from the WS Blog's coverage.

- The meeting went for an hour and a half instead of one hour and I suspect that will be the case for nearly all the other meetings to come.

- It seems that it was harder for Sanislo parents to attend the meeting than Highland Park parents. 

- Enrollment at the two schools still totals about 460 (in November 2024, it was Sanislo 153 and HP 306; now it’s 124 and 339, according to the district’s monthly enrollment report). 

- He (Shuldiner) said they looked around at the district’s 100+ schools and found 10 that were candidates for mergers.

Well, that's a cagey answer because the district didn't just "look around." They know and have known for a long time which buildings they wanted to close. We know this because Facilities has been building mega elementaries for quite some time even as enrollment was declining and was never expected to grow. 

- He mentioned a consideration for Sanislo to go into Louisa Boren STEM K-8 but it seemed a mismatch because of grade levels. I think it might have been good to ASK Sanislo this question. If you are in a K-8 school, there is no obligation to continue on there for middle school. And I hear from good things about Boren (if only they had a better building).

- He also said families might be concerned about staff (which the subsequent Q&A confirmed they were) – “Nobody is losing their job,” he promised. “Every single person who works at the two schools will still be employed.” He said attrition in the district meant “there’ll always be places.” Also, not everyone might opt to come over. Shuldiner said they’d also be working on formulas that will make sure staffing is correct.

- He also said the district would NOT be selling any buildings but mentioned partnering with a library or community center. For some reason, he did not mention that charter schools have the right of first refusal for any school building closed that is up for sale or lease. 

- First year, Highland Park’s Mary McDaniel and Sanislo’s Erika Ayer would be co-principals. After that, the most senior principal would stay. The other principal would have a place to go somewhere else in the district – “we have 106 schools.” The contract is what would require seniority to be considered for leadership, he initially said, though the second questioner countered that. Ultimately, Shuldiner said, they hadn’t quite worked out how the long-term leadership decision would be made. The superintendent said “past practice” might have to be taken into consideration. The parent who asked the question noted that beyond seniority, “There might be some intangible qualities” that families might want to consider. 

So does the PASS contract say seniority wins out or not? That's definitely something to find out.

- Another HP parent voiced support for principal McDaniel and then asked about staff numbers. They might have to add classrooms, she said; the superintendent said they’d done work on that. The parent also asked about counseling resources. Shuldiner had a formula for that – saying they could wind up with a FTE. And he said again that the decision on principal leadership after the first year could change.

"They have done work on adding classrooms?" That's another issue for mergers. It's one thing if a small school is merging into a newer, larger building where the space is already there. But is the district going to have to add classrooms at other buildings?

- One comment: She said that she was concerned about the lack of multiple scenarios from which to choose, that they were only being told one possibility is under consideration. She said for West Seattle, attendance zone issues were a concern; so was a shortage of dual-language programs.

“I’ve gotta play the hand that’s dealt to me,” Shuldiner replied, saying he’s working to make sure “each child gets the best posible education …” And as to “why are we doing this now?” he explained bluntly, “Because now is what we have.”

- Given the vote coming tonight on changing Board policy on closures and our discussion around governance, this below was an interesting exchange.

A Sanislo parent noted it’s the second attempt to close that school in two years, and “I want to go to a small neighborhood school …in Seattle we crave small walkable community hubs.” She said she doesn’t feel there’s a choice, with one plan placed on the table. Why “as a new leader” has Shuldiner returned to a plan that “the city rejected” two years ago? (The School Board canceled the closure plan two weeks after the 2024 Sanislo meeting we mentioned above.) She also noted that the 80 or so people in the room last night are not representative of everyone from both schools,” suggesting not enough was done to bring others into the discussion.

Shuldiner noted that the final decision is not in his hands – “I have zero power.” He reiterated that this is “meeting number 25 out of 47,” while the parent said, “For many people here, it’s (the first).” She also asked why this district isn’t suing the state like other districts; he said those other districts have some things involved that SPS does not but if they win, it’s good news. The parent countered that it’s important to look at historical reasons why Sanislo is under-enrolled – “our enrollment has been strangled by the district,” with past problems including transportation cuts in the 2010s. He said “I can’t do anything about fixing the past. … We’re trying to figure out if we can get all our 50,000 kids into” a school that’s best for them.

"I have zero power." He's gonna lay it all at the feet of the Board just as the Board is likely to vote to change the closure policy to give him MORE power? Sigh

As well, the "not fixing the past" statement - it is true that he can't change what happened in the past but fix obvious issues in the past that are ongoing? Yes, he can.

- The superintendent continued to contend that what’s being proposed is a merger, not a closure, and that it was different from what was planned in 2024 (though our archives suggest the plan, and terminology, was pretty much the same).

Schuldiner says it's a merger because "they are moving everyone into the new school." But he also said this:

For families worried about wanting to choose their child(ren)’s school based on the outcome, he promised that open enrollment would continue post-decision “for at least one more week, with impacted students having dibs.” 

So on paper, everyone is moving to the new school but the reality during open enrollment might be very different. 

- What about “developmental preschool”? the parent reiterated. “Preschool is a very different piece of this,” Shuldiner replied, but overall, the district is looking at where preschool might belong – especially when it doesn’t feed into the rest of the school. He said he couldn’t speak about where preK fits in with the district; “you ARE the district,” the parent retorted.

That is a good question because the district has allowed the City's PreK to go into many elementary schools. I'll have to cross-check and see if any of the schools possibly to be closed have a City Pre-K in them.

- Sanislo had gotten the short end of the stick so many times that “there feels like there’s no reason to be doing this – I don’t see the urgency and the need.” The superintendent insisted it would mean more resources for Sanislo; the questioner disagreed. “You want us to trust you that you’re going to resource kids better.”

Former Superintendent Jones had this same issue so show us the resources!

- An HP parent who had been a Sanislo parent said he feels “very vested in both communities” and said he supports the merger as “an opportunity to give Sanislo kids the best foot forward.” He said expectations at Sanislo had been low. He said it’s important to hold students to high expectations and so it would be important to make this “successful for everyone.” 

Sometimes at these meetings you will hear things said out loud that maybe the person might want to reconsider. How does this HP parents know that over at Sanislo they have low expectations? More than a bit of a dig there.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Tuesday Open Thread

Nepotism in Seattle Schools

Kindergarten Sibling Waitlists Explained