More Things that Make You Go, Hmmm
United Opt-Out, a website that has state-by-state resources for parents on how to opt their children out of tests got hacked recently. They say it was "maliciously hacked and destroyed in an act of political sabotage."
Odd, no? I mean, it's not Target or any money-making entity where you could get credit card info. It's information for public school parents. And yet it didn't just get temporarily interrupted - it got destroyed.
From Reclaim Reform:
How much money is involved for investors in the highly lucrative fields of testing, online programming, training, publishing, vendor contracts, etc.? The latest estimates from a Bill Moyers interview with Diane Ravitch is about $500 billion annually. View/read HERE.
And, of course, there is the power in directing the course of public education. I'm sure some ed reformers could not have that taken away from them.
On Common Core and popular support (which supporters insist is huge). There was a survey done recently, with less than 4,000 registered voters nationwide (1,000 nationwide, with additional ones in Florida, Ohio, Michigan, Illinois and Colorado - no explanation how they chose these states).
What was the question asked?
Oh, and do your like mom and apple pie, too? Of course they got 64% support with that question.
The results were 32% strongly support, 32% somewhat support, unsure 12%, oppose somewhat 9% and strongly oppose 15%. What's interesting is supporters are saying only 24% oppose them and leave out that 15% aren't sure about them at all.
All the questions were skewed that way. But they asked one telling question:
Not sure if you missed this but Maya Angelou and 120 other children's book authors signed a letter to President Obama about what they say is "overuse and abuse" of standardized testing. Here's a link to the letter.
We are alarmed at the negative impact of excessive school testing mandates, including your Administration’s own initiatives, on children’s love of reading and literature.
Teachers, parents and students agree with British author Philip Pullman who said, “We are creating a generation that hates reading and feels nothing but hostility for literature.”
We offer our full support for a national campaign to change the way we assess learning so that schools nurture creativity, exploration, and a love of literature from the first day of school through high school graduation.
Next, let's reflect on DFER. It's interesting that the huge pushback on Common Core has unleashed a lot of nervousness on the ed reform side because it is coming more from parents than anyone else. So bring on the tired old ed reform talk of (along with some new favorites) from DFER:
Odd, no? I mean, it's not Target or any money-making entity where you could get credit card info. It's information for public school parents. And yet it didn't just get temporarily interrupted - it got destroyed.
From Reclaim Reform:
How much money is involved for investors in the highly lucrative fields of testing, online programming, training, publishing, vendor contracts, etc.? The latest estimates from a Bill Moyers interview with Diane Ravitch is about $500 billion annually. View/read HERE.
And, of course, there is the power in directing the course of public education. I'm sure some ed reformers could not have that taken away from them.
On Common Core and popular support (which supporters insist is huge). There was a survey done recently, with less than 4,000 registered voters nationwide (1,000 nationwide, with additional ones in Florida, Ohio, Michigan, Illinois and Colorado - no explanation how they chose these states).
What was the question asked?
“To ensure that all students are prepared for success after
graduation, the Common Core Standards establish a set of clear,
consistent guidelines for what students should know and be able to
do at each grade level across subjects.”
Oh, and do your like mom and apple pie, too? Of course they got 64% support with that question.
The results were 32% strongly support, 32% somewhat support, unsure 12%, oppose somewhat 9% and strongly oppose 15%. What's interesting is supporters are saying only 24% oppose them and leave out that 15% aren't sure about them at all.
All the questions were skewed that way. But they asked one telling question:
Respondents were also asked if they would be more likely or less likely
“to support a candidate for public office that supported the use of
Common Core Standards in your area?”
They got the same results with that question as well. And yet, ed reformers are constantly berating any pushback or discussion about Common Core, saying the other side is "politicizing the discussion." Well, if you run a national poll about Common Core and have a question that would make CC a litmus test for candidates, then it is YOU who would be politicizing the conversation.
They got the same results with that question as well. And yet, ed reformers are constantly berating any pushback or discussion about Common Core, saying the other side is "politicizing the discussion." Well, if you run a national poll about Common Core and have a question that would make CC a litmus test for candidates, then it is YOU who would be politicizing the conversation.
Not sure if you missed this but Maya Angelou and 120 other children's book authors signed a letter to President Obama about what they say is "overuse and abuse" of standardized testing. Here's a link to the letter.
We are alarmed at the negative impact of excessive school testing mandates, including your Administration’s own initiatives, on children’s love of reading and literature.
Teachers, parents and students agree with British author Philip Pullman who said, “We are creating a generation that hates reading and feels nothing but hostility for literature.”
We offer our full support for a national campaign to change the way we assess learning so that schools nurture creativity, exploration, and a love of literature from the first day of school through high school graduation.
Next, let's reflect on DFER. It's interesting that the huge pushback on Common Core has unleashed a lot of nervousness on the ed reform side because it is coming more from parents than anyone else. So bring on the tired old ed reform talk of (along with some new favorites) from DFER:
- "status quo" - that one never seems to get old to them even though they probably could not bring forth a handful of public school parents or taxpayers who would say everything is fine and nothing should change.
- "outdated pencil and paper bubble tests" - Now I'm not sure which one is worse - the dreaded paper and pencil test or the bubble test. I can point out that much of technology today got invented by people who took...pencil and paper tests. In fact, the people who sent the astronauts to the moon? Took a paper and pencil test.
- "we need to let parents have an 'honest picture of how their students are doing" Okay, so how come parents can't see their own child's test results? What about teachers and the students in their class?
- my new favorite is "Some will use this opportunity to criticize the hard work of the educators and researchers who created the test." I cannot say - nor can DFER - who truly created these assessments. If you go by who "created" the CC standards, you'd have to wonder. Hard work does not equal good test. I thought we stopped giving grades for effort.
- I also like that the issues around the assessments are "hiccups" and "glitches."
- They "arrived" in Washington in 2011 and had 12 teachers that year. They are now all the way up to 26 teachers. It would appear that Washington State districts (and in particular Puget Sound districts) are not all that interested in what TFA has to offer.
- This region is coded on their national map as "green" which means, according to TFA, that the need for TFA is not great here for their teachers.
- The striking error is on their homepage where they reel off these stats about Rainier Beach High School and Garfield. I read these and thought, "wow, I didn't think those state test scores on African-American students at those schools were so low." Well, checking OSPI data, it turns out those are stats from 2011-2012 school year. The scores, especially at RBHS, have gone up quite a bit. And yet TFA uses those old stats to bolster their pitch that TFA is needed here.
Comments
Also, the work of these vendors was supervised by work groups made up entirely of state department of education staff.
Since Washington/OSPI is the fiscal agent for the consortium, OSPI technically awarded the contracts.
--- swk
But why would you assume they would be educators? Wouldn't you want people who are skilled in test development working on developing tests. Most K-12 educators have no background in such --- it is simply not their forte. Ask all of the teachers principals that you know if they have any coursework or professional development in item writing, test construction, scoring, psychometrics, etc. --- you'll not be surprised at the answer.
Finally, as I previously mentioned, all of the work of Smarter Balanced is supervised by work groups of state department of education staff.
--- swk
--enough already
Because Common Core has been so badly explained and the implementation so bungled, I have very little faith in it (as is apparent here).
Read on!