A Compassionate Teacher's Note to Students

A teacher in Indiana wrote this note to his students as they started testing.

On behalf of critically thinking educators everywhere, I would like to apologize to you for having to participate in this absurd ritual.

 And I would like to remind you that whatever score the ACT labels you with, consciousness is not quantified and this test does not determine your intelligence, capacity for critical thought, compassion or your worth as a human being.

Thank you, (the aptly named) Mr. Robinson.

Comments

Anonymous said…
Are we anti-ACT now? If so - why? Are his students required to take the ACT? It's generally voluntary.

I saw a comment on one of the pro-More For Mann websites that the MAP and AP exams play a role in class and race stratification.

That comment and this teacher's criticism of the ACT make no sense to me.

Lynn
9/25/13, 10:20 AM
Melissa Westbrook said…
Why do people perceive that if we put up threads, it means we against/for something?

I'm for the ACT but I think this was an act of compassion on the part of a teacher who recognizes the level of stress these students are probably going thru because of the number of tests they are taking in a year.
9/25/13, 10:33 AM
Anonymous said…
Compassionate, maybe. Irresponsible, definitely. The message delivered by Mr. Robinson in his note the day of testing could have been delivered throughout the school year and not on the day of testing. He pretty much ensured that his students underperformed that day. Let's hope there were no stakes attached to the ACT that day.

--- what are people thinking?
9/25/13, 10:34 AM
Anonymous said…
It was probably actually the ACT version of the PSAT although, some school districts are using ACT and SAT scores instead of HSPE or EOCs.

HP
9/25/13, 11:04 AM
Anonymous said…
HP, no district is using ACT or SAT scores instead of the HSPE or EOCs. While ACT or SAT scores may be used by students as alternative assessments for graduation purposes, students have to take the HSPE and the EOCs before they can use alternative assessments.

Also, a high school's accountability is based on the HSPE and EOCs, not alternative assessments. Therefore, all students (except students with significant cognitive disabilities) are taking the HSPE and EOCs.

--- swk
9/25/13, 11:18 AM
dw said…
I agree with "what are people thinking". His message could have been delivered in a positive way throughout the year (though frankly, if he wrote this on the day of testing, I'd guess he belittled testing in general throughout the year as well).

This teacher may have felt like he was helping his students, but he likely hurt them instead. Most kids who are actually taking the ACT have vested interest in doing well on it, with real world consequences, like where you will be accepted for college.

Regardless of how you feel about this kind of testing, you need to be supportive of your kids and help them to do their best, not blow it off, because that's the system right now. Use your efforts outside the classroom to work to change the system if you like, but don't harm children who might otherwise have the ability and/or drive to get into a competitive college or university.

Besides that, his message is only half right. He's right that tests like the ACT do not measure compassion or worth as a human being. That's a good point, and important to remember in life. But well-designed tests, whether high stakes or low stakes, can indeed measure capacity for critical thought, among other useful things, and most importantly to the schools themselves, the likelihood of success in their college or university. For better or worse, it's why they're used. Fortunately, most colleges use a variety of methods to determine who gets accepted, and not every quality college puts SAT/ACT scores at the top of the heap.

I'd give this teacher a "B" for effort, but an "F" for helping his kids, at least on that particular day.
9/25/13, 11:33 AM
Anonymous said…
swk,

The teacher is in Illinois - not Washington.

Lynn
9/25/13, 12:27 PM
Anonymous said…
Look into Gatto's "Bartleby Project" of nonviolent resistance to standardized tests. Just say "I would prefer not to".

bartlebyproject.com

open ears
9/25/13, 1:26 PM
Anonymous said…
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
9/25/13, 1:59 PM
A-mom said…
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
9/25/13, 2:05 PM
Anonymous said…
Wow! Almost all of you missed the (data) P O I N T.

~ Why don't you Get It?
9/25/13, 4:47 PM
Anonymous said…
I know for sure that I missed your P O I N T.

--- what are people thinking?
9/25/13, 4:59 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Tuesday Open Thread

The speaker list is up for the Board meeting tomorrow; not as packed as I thought with just four people on the waitlist. The majority of the speakers are speaking on high school boundaries (with several wanting to talk about Ballard High). There are only three of us speaking about the Green Dot resolution asking the City to not grant the zoning departures that Green Dot has requested.  It's me, long-time watchdog, Chris Jackins, and the head of the Washington State Charter Schools Association, Patrick D'Amelio.  (I knew Mr. D'Amelio when he headed the Alliance for Education and Big Brothers and Big Sisters; he's a stand-up guy.)
Read more

Breaking It Down: Where the District Might Close Schools

Update 2: an absolutely fabulous interactive map made by parent Beth Day (@thebethocracy on Twitter - she covers Board meetings and is fun to read).   end of update    Update 1: Mea culpa, I did indeed get Decatur and Thornton Creek mixed up. Thanks to all for the correction. end of update   I suspect some who read this post will be irate. Why do this? Because the district seems very hellbent on this effort with no oversight skid marks from the Board.    To clearly state - I do not believe that closing 20 schools is a good idea. I think they hit on 20 because they thought it might bring in the most savings. But the jury is still out on the savings because the district has not shown its work nor its data. I suspect closing schools and THEN leasing/renting them is the big plan but that means the district really has to keep the buildings up.   But this district, with its happy talk about "well-resourced schools" is NOT acknowledging the pain and yes, gr...
Read more

Education News Roundup

From the ever-amusing Washington Policy Center : Vouchers are Pell Grants for students under 18.  Vouchers are no different than Pell Grants or GI benefits, except the money goes to the families of students younger than age 18.  Except they are. Pell Grants were created to help needy students and that's not really the goal of the voucher program.  The Pell grant website does have a couple of great studies on why low-income students drop out before finishing their higher ed and what makes a difference.
Read more