Seattle Schools Explains Smarter Balanced Testing
The district has quite a bit of information for parents on the new Smarter Balanced testing on this page.
It's great that the district has put up this information (I'm not sure how long it has been up - I saw this on Facebook via a reader). But, there's a lot of ed lingo in there and I really wonder many parents will truly understand it all. There is also a lot of language that is somewhat but not totally true.
For example:
These online assessments are designed to measure how well students are meeting new academic standards designed to better prepare them for college, career and life.
Maybe for community college but probably not many four-year colleges. That should be made clear.
Or how about this:
Rigor: Students will not be able to rely as much on process-of-elimination to find an answer. The assessment includes some multiple choice with more than one answer as well as other demands for higher-level thinking.
I'm hoping that this "more than one answer" issue is being addressed by teachers. I also think it worth having parents tell their kids that it might seem that there is more than one answer.
Even the math assessment includes some short-answer writing.
As you may recall, this was an issue on the WASL math as it seemed more about reading than math. Let me know what your student says. This disadvantages ELL students.
Interactive: More than just multiple-choice, students may be asked to drag-and-drop answers, complete a chart or highlight evidence.
Boy, your kid better know how to use a computer.
Remember that scoring shifts are normal whenever more rigorous academics and their assessments are introduced; teachers and students need time to adjust. Please know that this year’s scores will be viewed as a new baseline that will help our teachers (and families) measure future growth.
And teachers and school leaders will recalibrate their expectations.
All this to really say - don't be shocked by your student's score. It might be lower than your expectations. You might need to "recalibrate" that expectation and know that maybe it's the test rigor, not your kid.
For this reason, most third-graders with a Level 1 score (out of four levels) on the English language arts assessment will be scheduled for a teacher conference before the end of the year. Because schools need those scores early in order to make time for the state-mandated conferences, third-graders will be the first to take the English language arts assessment.
FYI, for third grade parents.
Here's what the district says on refusal to take the test:
As to point two, a zero only negatively impacts the school's overall results if there are a lot of them. And, what does that really even mean?
As to point three, see my point one.
As to point four, see my point one. As well, you will be receiving results from all the OTHER testing done on your child.
As to point five, there are other things to do to avoid remedial classes in college.
As to point six, well, the kids taking the test aren't receiving instruction, either.
It's great that the district has put up this information (I'm not sure how long it has been up - I saw this on Facebook via a reader). But, there's a lot of ed lingo in there and I really wonder many parents will truly understand it all. There is also a lot of language that is somewhat but not totally true.
For example:
These online assessments are designed to measure how well students are meeting new academic standards designed to better prepare them for college, career and life.
Maybe for community college but probably not many four-year colleges. That should be made clear.
Or how about this:
Rigor: Students will not be able to rely as much on process-of-elimination to find an answer. The assessment includes some multiple choice with more than one answer as well as other demands for higher-level thinking.
I'm hoping that this "more than one answer" issue is being addressed by teachers. I also think it worth having parents tell their kids that it might seem that there is more than one answer.
Even the math assessment includes some short-answer writing.
As you may recall, this was an issue on the WASL math as it seemed more about reading than math. Let me know what your student says. This disadvantages ELL students.
Interactive: More than just multiple-choice, students may be asked to drag-and-drop answers, complete a chart or highlight evidence.
Boy, your kid better know how to use a computer.
Remember that scoring shifts are normal whenever more rigorous academics and their assessments are introduced; teachers and students need time to adjust. Please know that this year’s scores will be viewed as a new baseline that will help our teachers (and families) measure future growth.
And teachers and school leaders will recalibrate their expectations.
All this to really say - don't be shocked by your student's score. It might be lower than your expectations. You might need to "recalibrate" that expectation and know that maybe it's the test rigor, not your kid.
For this reason, most third-graders with a Level 1 score (out of four levels) on the English language arts assessment will be scheduled for a teacher conference before the end of the year. Because schools need those scores early in order to make time for the state-mandated conferences, third-graders will be the first to take the English language arts assessment.
FYI, for third grade parents.
Here's what the district says on refusal to take the test:
- Students who do not participate will receive a "zero" score on the assessment and no score report for teachers or families to view.
- A zero will negatively impact the school's overall results.
- Teachers will not receive results that could be used as a tool to measure the student's academic growth.
- Families will not receive results that will enable them to chart the student's growth over time.
- High school juniors without assessment results will not be eligible for the remedial testing waiver offered by state colleges (see above).
- Students who do not participate will receive supervision but not instruction during assessment time.
As to point two, a zero only negatively impacts the school's overall results if there are a lot of them. And, what does that really even mean?
As to point three, see my point one.
As to point four, see my point one. As well, you will be receiving results from all the OTHER testing done on your child.
As to point five, there are other things to do to avoid remedial classes in college.
As to point six, well, the kids taking the test aren't receiving instruction, either.
Comments
http://www.ascd.org/ASCD/pdf/siteASCD/policy/2014/Austin-Communicating-Standards-and-Assessments.pdf
I'm disappointed in the district. I'm not seeing a lot of critical analysis.
"Rigor: Students will not be able to rely as much on process-of-elimination to find an answer. The assessment includes some multiple choice with more than one answer as well as other demands for higher-level thinking."
Translation: Let's really mess with the minds of eight year old children.
Teachers take classes to create tests. Part of testing is NOT to make children feel overwhelmed, but to help achieve a sense of mastery.
One should research child development and the need for mastery.
curious
BREAKING NEWS!
Director Peters and Director Patu have submitted a resolution to suspend administration of SBAC!
I hope we can get a thread on this issue!!
Here is the resolution:
http://www.seattleschools.org/modules/groups/homepagefiles/cms/1583136/File/Departmental%20Content/school%20board/14-15%20agendas/030415agenda/20150304_AssessmentsResolution_DRAFT.pdf
Doubt it will pass but good on Peters and Patu. At the least it will draw attention to the issue.
DistrictWatcher
http://sbac.portal.airast.org/practice-test/
You hit the green box and then just click on “sign in,” no need to create an account. From there you choose your grade level and link to ELA or math.
SPS Teacher
Please, vote to spare my girl! Save her from fearing math!
-sadmom
--Consequences?
I found info on 6th grade math placement on the Advanced Learning website.
https://www.k12.wa.us/assessment/StateTesting/TestStatistics.aspx
-just fyi
Don't forget the enormous sums spent on training teachers to teach to the Common Core.
David Edelman
--Consequences?
Here's my understanding: If your child is in APP@Lincoln, then the default math placement would be 8th grade math (CMP3) in 6th grade. Only if you anticipate your child wanting to accelerate to Algebra 1 in 6th grade (and they are currently in APP/HCC) would the math matrix criteria be of concern. If your child is not in HCC, but in Spectrum or at your neighborhood school, then the math placement matrix would allow for acceleration to the APP level math pathway or beyond.
-just fyi
Essentially, any student--whether coming from HCC, Spectrum, ALO or GenEd--can qualify for Alg 1 in 6th if they have the scores. Isn't that right?
HIMSmom
Only if you anticipate your [currently enrolled in elementary HCC - Lincoln, Fairmount, or TM] child wanting to accelerate to Algebra 1 in 6th grade...would the math matrix criteria be of concern [to a currently enrolled in elementary HCC student].
Otherwise, If your child is not in HCC, but in Spectrum or at your neighborhood school, then the math placement matrix would allow for acceleration to the APP level math pathway or beyond. "Or beyond" should include Algebra 1 in 6th, but it's my understanding individual non-HCC middle schools may discourage such placement.
The original question was about opting out of SBAC as a current 4th grader. If enrolled in HCC and not anticipating taking Algebra 1 in 6th, there may be little risk in opting out (but who knows?, the rules seem to keep changing). If not enrolled in HCC, but anticipating accelerating along the math pathway come middle school, then opting out of SBAC may not be in your student's best interest.
my 2cents
--Consequences